As an author you have to believe in your book.Experience has taught me that if you don’t, nobody will.Still, there are ways of believing in your book while keeping your ego in check.Given the ego we’ve seen along Pennsylvania Avenue these last few years it may come as little surprise that even some wannabe authors can nearly match it.The line, as professionals draw it, is balancing between the importance of your work with the realism that few books sell well. Your best approach, as author, is humility.Many people don’t read the professionals.You quickly learn this if you’re in an editorial role.It is normal to receive emails from authors telling you how important their work is, some even claiming it as an even on a cosmic scale (I am not joking).
I often consider how much pain authors could spare themselves with just a tiny bit of research.If a publisher has turned your book down twice already, don’t submit it a third time.(You already crossed the line the second time you sent it.)And don’t send your proposal with a list of demands.What I’ve noted both on this blog and elsewhere is that editors value professionalism.We don’t like turning down books.We don’t want to ruin a prospective author’s day.There are, however, safeguards you can use to prevent the worst kinds of disappointment.Rule number one is check your ego at the door.Do you know how many books have been published?Do you know just how difficult it will be for your book to get noticed?Take a reality check.
Also, scale your expectations.How many bestsellers have come from university presses?If you’re after bestseller status you need to aim for a trade publisher.This is pretty basic stuff.Those of us who publish in the academic world do believe our books are important, but many of us also know that they start only small conversations.Biblical studies isn’t exactly a growth field.We talk amongst each other, a collegial little group for the most part.And to keep things on the collegial level it is helpful to remember that we’re not publishing for ego.We’re publishing to try to move knowledge ahead, even if just by a micron or two.Good writing, I was once told, is simply clear thinking.Getting that writing published is part of a conversation and conversation only works ifwe are willing to keep our egos on their leashes.
There are not too many books that I would call epiphanies.I always lay down Jeffrey Kripal’s books with a sense of wonder and awe.His Secret Body: Erotic and Esoteric Currents in the History of Religions is one book I initially skipped over due (as usual) to not being able to afford even modest academic pricing.(Hey, my books are even worse in that regard, so that’s not a criticism!)I’ve met Kripal a few times and have had some conversations with him that always leave me feeling strangely empowered.That’s the place this book left me.I’m a slow reader and it isn’t a small tome, so it took me some time.Also, I didn’t want to rush it.Doing so would’ve been like trying to jog across a boulder field.I hardly know where to begin.
Kripal is an historian of religions.His own experiences in the academy are narrated in this book, so I urge the curious to look.Many people who know me think that I’m a biblical scholar.My training, however, is in history of religions.It’s a fool’s errand to try to classify a doctorate, but my focus was on how ideas appeared in several ancient cultures, with no real expectation of evolution beyond what appeared later in time than something else.As many who study ancient texts know, this translates to “biblical studies” in the academy and so for many years I taught Hebrew Bible.Friends in the academy suggested I should shift my research to Bible (as I did in Weathering the Psalms) in order to get a solid placement in academe.It backfired in my case.This isn’t a pointless digression.
Secret Body is a trippy book.It deserves to be read widely and engaged with by academics (among which I no longer count).It is a ground plan for the study of our field.Kripal understands, better than just about anyone, why religious studies is foundering.He’s also brave enough to delve into the unspoken areas that we all know are terribly, terribly significant.And he isn’t a materialist.There’s much in this book to give the reader pause.Indeed, it’s more than a stop sign on the superhighway of the academic business.It’s the kind of book you need to keep at hand in case “the real world” gets you ensnared in its ropes and chains.It makes me believe that I need to go back to school all over again.
My heart goes out to academic authors.It really does.They labor over a book important to their field and see it come out costing near triple digits and wonder why it’s not in the local bookstore.There is, however, a very wide gap between academic and trade publishing.It is bridged here and there by authors who value readers over reputation, but unless you deliberately try to learn how all of this works, it is bewildering.Academics, you see, are area specialists by and large.You don’t write a dissertation on the Bible, for example, but on a specific part of the Bible (New Testament or Hebrew Bible).And within that section your specialization is not a single book, but often a small part of a book, or a theme.I’ve seen dissertations written on a single Hebrew word.Specialization.
With all of this tight focus, it’s easy to forget what browsing in a bookstore’s like.Even with some of the incredible brick and mortar stores in Edinburgh, technical books had to be ordered—this was before Amazon.When you check the books of colleagues out of libraries it doesn’t always occur that you do this because libraries are the only places that buy such books.And with the explosion of doctoral degrees in shrinking areas of studies (there are no jobs here, folks!) the number of published dissertations has skyrocketed.Even advanced scholars forget the average reading public would find their work impenetrable.It’s not going to be in the local bookstore, and it costs so much because it sells so few copies.I do feel for academic authors.
In addition to all the area specialization, it would make sense to research the academic publishing industry.Yes, it is an industry—it has to try to turn a profit when sales are minimal.And with so many books being published, libraries can’t keep up.The end result is high prices.I’m as guilty as the next academic at wishing economics would just go away and leave me alone.I want to believe in the pursuit of knowledge for knowledge’s sake. That’s not the way the world works, however.At least not the publishing world in a capitalistic context.The internet itself has become competition.Much of the information’s out there for free.So your academic book, when it comes out, will be priced out of your comfort range (been there, done that).It’s not that your publisher doesn’t believe in you, but that they have to try to turn a profit.All it takes to understand why is a bit of research.
A recent post of mine on the United Methodist Church got a lot of response (for me, anyway) on other social media.As I pondered this—I’ve written about the topic many times before—it occurred to me that most people probably have no idea what biblical scholars do all day.(That is, besides write books that only other biblical scholars read, and teach their classes, or, very occasionally, edit books.)Biblical studies is arguably one of the oldest academic pursuits in the world and what it boils down to in a word is “contexts.”We try to understand the multiple contexts of the biblical texts.Think about this a second: when you pick up a book, newspaper, magazine, or their electronic equivalents, what is the first, if often unconscious, thought you have?Isn’t it something like “what kind of book, newspaper, etc., is this?”Is it fiction or non?Is it reputable or not?Who wrote it and when?These are all contexts.
The Bible was written about two millennia ago.Very little of that original context still remains.In fact, none of the original manuscripts even still exist.It was a book written in Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek.The vast majority of people in the western world do not read these languages, and so the Bible comes to us in mediated form—translation.Translation, as any writer knows, is a form of interpretation.It is not, and can never be, the original.To figure out what the Bible “means” it has to be interpreted—even just reading it is a form of interpretation.Biblical scholars want to be able to interpret it in informed ways.We learn about its various contexts and use them to help us understand.
What did people think like thousands of years ago?Can you even remember what it was like to look up a distant location without the internet?Writing letters or dialing a rotary phone to get information on it?Going to triple A to get maps?And all of that was only two decades ago.Life in biblical times was very different than life today.The people then didn’t understand science the way that we do.The writers of the Good Book didn’t have any idea that what they were scribbling would one day be considered holy scripture.They had completely different contexts.Whether the contexts are historical, literary, or social scientific (we still haven’t figured out an elegant way of saying the latter) biblical scholars use a variety of methods to get to those contexts.We can’t go in with the answers already in our heads—if we did we’d only find what we were looking for.At the end we have an answer, not “the” answer.And so biblical studies continues.
One of the things you see quite a lot of as an editor is “the next big thing.” Authors with an ego that awes me ensure me that this book will be the sea change we’ve all been waiting for. Things will be different after this is published. I don’t blame them. The trades all say that you’ve got to convince the editor that this project is worth her or his while. Overstating the case is par on this course. All of this got me to thinking. If you’ve read biblical studies seriously you’ll recognize the name Wellhausen. I don’t even have to use his first name—you know who I mean, right? Well, we’ve gone beyond the days when you could be a Wellhausen. When I was a student people spoke of the Wright, Bright, and Albright school. We knew who each of these gentlemen was. Now there are so many spoons in the pot that we’re not even certain what’s cooking.
Have you seen this man?
I’m not sure what the attraction to advanced degrees in this area is. If my case is anything to go by (and I don’t claim that it is) you grow up in a Bible reading family and you want to take the next logical steps. When you’re far enough along on the path to realize what’s happened, it’s too late to turn back. Many things in life are that way. There is a tipping point, a moment of crisis, then nothing will be the same. Then you learn you’ll never be the new Wellhausen. There was only one, and that was a couple of centuries ago now. I run into some pretty strange stuff when it comes to ways of reading the Bible. When the dust settles, however, we’ll still be counting J, E, D, and P on our fingers.
This isn’t a field for fame. Don’t believe me? Approach a stranger on the street and ask them if they know who Wellhausen is. Alas and alack, one of our greatest names is nobody outside the academy! In my own days among the privileged professorate, I never suspected I’d be anything but one of many voices trying to be heard. After all, my training was really more in history of religions than Bible in the first place. Dead languages had to be negotiated, but that’s all part of becoming an expert in something nobody really cares about. But then I think of Wellhausen. There was a time when all of this could make a nation such as Germany sit up and take notice. That day was centuries ago, and I’d better check that pot—I think maybe whatever’s in it may be done.
Sidelines can be interesting places to sit. You’re close to the action, and you’re privileged with a close view that few others have. You can’t, however, play the game. Sidelines are familiar to biblical scholars. I can’t count the number of times and/or ways the input of those who spend their lives trying to comprehend the Good Book are, well, sidelined. In the publishing world those who work with Bibles are simply ignored by most others, despite the enormous revenue Bible sales generate. In the academy religion departments overall are fair game for any potential budget cuts. And since what religion study survives tends to be intercultural, the Bible faculty are deemed somewhat less necessary than other sub-disciplines. It’s easy to forget that Christianity is the largest organized religion in the world and that some 2.2 billion persons claim that name. The Bible’s their foundational book. It tells us what motivates them. And yet, it’s easier simply to ignore the whole thing. Then something insane like an Evangelical-fueled Trump election, and everyone continues to say, “we can safely ignore this.”
I recently saw an article by scientists which explored why people engage in dangerous behaviors. The main idea was that although we know certain things are bad for us individually or as a planet, we still do them. We do them with the full knowledge that they’re deadly and will likely hasten our demise. Ignoring religion (and in the case at hand, the Bible) is very much like that. A well-armed true believer can ruin your day pretty quickly. Religion, in recent years, has generated over $82 billion in revenue per year. At least those in the dismal science ought to sit up and take notice of that! Hey, for once, the numbers are with us! Statistically, religion is very important. Sounds like a good thing to pretend doesn’t exist.
Having grown up a Fundamentalist, I often ponder this state of affairs. The Bible, we all knew, was the most important thing. Studying it formally does tend to force new ways of considering it, but few Bible scholars would want to dismiss the Good Book out of hand. It still means too much to too many people simply to ignore. Far safer is the proper handling of Holy Writ. This is much easier to instill when institutions support it. It really is a necessary kind of education. Still, it gets sidelined for industries with lesser profits and lesser baggage. I grew into a career defined by the Bible, but even if I hadn’t I’d hope that I’d be able to recognize that some things just shouldn’t be ignored. Yet I’m on the sidelines cheering on those who consider such a career a tragic mistake.