The transition between Lemony Snicket’s The Wide Window and The Miserable Mill, volumes three and four, respectively, of A Series of Unfortunate Events, is the gulf between what was portrayed in the 2004 movie and what wasn’t. The books do show their age a bit in that some of the villains might be considered offensive these days, but the writing is clever and even educational. Dealing with two of them together is, like the film, an attempt to forge a transition. The Wide Window, which is both compressed and elaborated in the movie, doesn’t resolve itself as portrayed on the screen. Of course Count Olaf is at large again and the Baudelaire orphans are left homeless once more. In the movie Jim Carrey’s Captain Sham is perhaps his best character with his attempts at a cross between a sea captain and a Newfoundland landlubber. The book raises the ethical issue of what laws it’s permissible to break to save your life, which is missing in the film.
The Miserable Mill, book four, reflects how dark these tales can be without the movie to lighten the mood a bit. Maybe not quite enough to categorize them as horror, but enough to make them somewhat scary. Here the orphans have reached the end of their family connections and are passed off to the owner of a lumber mill who puts them to work right away. Of course, Count Olaf is lurking nearby and is working with an ophthalmologist who specializes in hypnosis. It is actually a frightening thought to be hypnotized against your will. The orphans learn to appreciate how difficult their siblings’ specializations are and, of course, make it through together.
Hypnosis is something I’ve never experienced. I went to a show once where the stage performer attempted to hypnotize the audience. I was fervently religious at the time, and it didn’t work on me. I’d read that religious people are difficult to hypnotize (that is, those who haven’t been hypnotized already). Since that time I’ve been curious if I might be hypnotized as an adult, and, if so, what it would be like. As a mental state, hypnosis is still poorly understood. It is used in literature, not uncommonly in horror. I will, of course, continue working my way through A Series of Unfortunate Events because once you get started it’s difficult to stop. It is obvious, however, that I’ve watched the film enough to have a sense of what transpired through The Wide Window. Now, with and after The Miserable Mill, I have little recollection of what might be ahead.














