I’m no Jane Goodall, but I grew up loving animals. I still do. I’d spend many hours poring over animal identification books. When I was young I could tell a crab from a lobster from a crayfish. I knew moths from butterflies. Megafauna? I had it covered. One thing, however, eluded me. Bird identification. Now, I can tell the obvious ones apart, but ornithology seems to delight in making the trade difficult. For example, I was on a walk with a couple friends in May. We spotted a small bird—smaller than finch size but larger than a hummingbird. Short tail. Its coloration was an unusual shade of brown. We got a good look at it. Back home I pulled out my bird identification books. Nothing like it. I tried online, even Cornell’s famed ornithology lab website. According to all the specs what we saw doesn’t exist.

The problem with birds is that they come in different colorations. Most bird identification books and sites focus on the males. They tend to be more colorful and their identification is easier. Not only that, but young birds’ plumage often changes as they mature. This is such an issue that some bird books warn the would-be watcher not to try to identify by the color. You should look for things like eye-rings, beak shapes, and that tiny spot on the tip of the tail, when seen in flight. Right. After a couple of days of searching in my spare time, I gave up. Given how small it was, this was likely a juvenile. Which sex I have no idea. It bothers me when I can’t identify what I see. The world is full of such wonderful things!
Many years ago in Scotland, some friends willingly crawled to a cliff’s edge with us on a rainy day in the Orkney Islands. We’d come here to see the puffins. Puffins nest on cliffs overlooking the sea. They have colorful bills and are similar in looks (but not physiognomy) to penguins. We were rewarded with a view of a cliff-full of sea-birds, including puffins. I often ponder, living inland now, why the bright, colorful birds tend to hide. I know, I know—predators. But still, I can count on one hand the number of times I’ve seen an adult male oriel with their bright orange plumage, despite living in an area where they’re listed as common. Birds can be so coy. Maybe that’s why dedicated bird watchers have such passion. I love animals. The problem with birds is, despite hours with books and websites, some of them I just can’t identify.

