The Evil That Men Do

The graveyards of humankind are filled with the victims of religious violence. That fact does not seem to have lessened the impact of religion as a whole on humankind. One reason may be that religion has been a focal point of the good and humanitarian deeds of which people are capable, as well as a justification of the most heinous. The irony is that adherents of a religion claim that a just, true and righteous god is their motivation, for good or for ill. In the same church, mosque, or synagogue, there are widely differing views that live together. Sometime the truce is an uneasy one. Sometimes the adherents are united against a common enemy.

The furor over whether a mosque should be permitted near Ground Zero has become a major political whipping boy. Heavyweights like Newt Gingrich and featherweights like Sarah Palin are quick to fire off their half-cocked mouths about the impropriety of it. Michael Bloomberg, the mayor of New York City has been given the task that kindergarten teachers around the country – around the world – should incorporate in their curriculum, the task of teaching tolerance. In an excellent speech delivered yesterday, the mayor reminded citizens of what many appear to have forgotten: without religious freedom nobody is free.

Muslims are not to be blamed for 9/11 any more than Christians are to be blamed for the Inquisition. Every religion has members that misuse their sacred trust as a vehicle for hate and repression. By forbidding religious freedom to any religious group, America sets a precedent of a growing intolerance that can only lead to more, and greater suffering. Already the Gingriches and Palins of our nation tell us that there are indeed lesser citizens and greater citizens. Those like them deserve freedom of religious expression, of marriage recognition, of family size, of medical care, and those who believe differently and therefore deserve less. Speaking only for myself, I would rather have tolerant Muslims as my neighbors than supersessionist Christians.

5 thoughts on “The Evil That Men Do

  1. Piper Bayard

    Thank you for your post.

    As a recovering attorney, I am completely sympathetic with the ideals of freedom of religion and separation of Church and State. However, this Ground Zero Mosque business is far more complex than a pure freedom of religion issue. Even if Imam Rauf and Daisy Khan are pure in their intentions, for security reasons, we can’t ignore what this would mean to the rest of the Islamic world. Because Islam puts such emphasis on sacred locations, particularly when they are built on top of the pre-existing sacred spaces of others, I seriously doubt that Muslims at large will hear the voice of moderate Islam in a mosque being built two blocks from Ground Zero. Politically, this will be a coup to our enemies. I am concerned that this perception of weakness will exacerbate the security issues we face as nation, both domestically and internationally.

    I do offer a solution, though. Rauf, Khan, and The Cordoba Initiative could make this a true “community center with an Islamic prayer space.” Rather than “consider an interfaith prayer space,” they could make it a cornerstone of this endeavor. They could include a counseling center to educate immigrant Muslims in American law and the expectations of residents in our country. They could staff a crisis line for people in fear of domestic violence and honor killings. If they make this a true community center for all of New York, that would be a statement to America and to the Islamic world that moderate Muslims really are actively opposed to jihadis, even if that means standing with Team Infidel. That is a message both sides need to hear before peace can prevail.

    Like

  2. POD Apocalypse

    Cordoba Center is an interesting name. A city in Spain where the muslims conquered in 711 and wasted no time in converting a gothic roman catholic church into a mosque to celebrate their dominant victory. If they want New Yorkers and Americans to show how open-minded we are and how we are willing to move forwards in tolerance, then the Muslims who want this cultural center should make an equal gesture, and name it instead Rushdie Van Gogh Center.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.