Have you ever read a book where factual errors make you question the larger picture? I suppose being trained in research makes me more bothered by small inaccuracies. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve made mistakes myself. Even in publications. But when they come near the beginning it’s rather unfortunate. That’s not to say I didn’t enjoy Allan Brown’s Inside The Wicker Man. I actually enjoyed it quite a lot. There’s a real treasure trove here for fans of this cult classic. I suspect it’s the definitive treatment of the misfortunes the film faced after it was shot, and even during the shooting process itself. It’s somewhat surprising that so many of us have even heard of it. When the film’s production company turns against the project it must present special difficulties. Errors are human. Most of the mistakes in the book were about religion.
For Wicker Man fans this book is a great resource. Not only does it tell the story, but it serves as a useful reference. It includes information on locations, script excerpts, and behind-the-scenes stories. You get to feel that you know the people involved beyond simply seeing them as characters in a play. One of the points that Brown makes, while obvious in retrospect, is crucial: The Wicker Man works as horror not in spite of religion, but because of religion. I struggle to articulate what the two share in common, but it is useful to be reminded that a prime example comes in this unusual movie. I wrote about it in Holy Horror, but there’s much even there that I left unsaid.
Brown had the distinct privilege of interviewing many of the people involved in the making of the film. Most of the cast and crew have since died—the movie was, after all, nearly half-a-century ago. Even so, when attempting to get at what a novel, movie, song, or piece of visual art means, the realization soon dawns that it’s often in the mind of the observer. Some songs, for example, speak intensely to some people while being ignored by many others. The Wicker Man never swam into the mainstream. I discovered it during an intense period of watching as much quality horror as I could get my hands on. Immediately I was struck by its intelligence and its strong message. I’ve watched it several times since, making me, I suppose, a fan. Enough of one to read this book and enjoy it, in any case. And to recommend it to others who may be interested in the fascinating film it explores, along with its religion.