The Bells

No matter how naïve I find myself, reading student papers always rings bells. They may be alarm bells of my own obsolescence or the tintinnabulation of a new era dawning. Either way, they scare me. Having spent many, many days concentrating on reading papers to the detriment of daily life, I have been submerged into a world that is foreign to me. Yes, I am used to students texting in class, and I know when their laptops are open for “taking notes” that university wi-fi networks are freely available for surfing the net. I know they are only paying half-attention. I may be old, but I’m not completely stupid. Well, not all students do this, but the practice is ubiquitous enough to be considered normative. Their world is a realm of electronic information. The old ways are passing.

I recently learned that footnoting is dead. Already-in-the-tomb-four-days dead. An art that my mediocre high school drilled into every student in English class is no longer even remembered. I even had good students report to me that the campus writing center housed no one who even ever used the Chicago Manual of Style, although some of them had heard of it. In mythology class, any book is referred to as a “novel” or “story” with no regard paid to its actual genre. For those weaned on electronic reading, the old distinctions no longer apply. The Internet is full of information, and many young people can’t discern the wheat from the chaff. Raise your hand if you know what “chaff” is. I didn’t think so.

Seeing all of this in the context of a mythology course is fascinating. Many students refer to the days when gods and monsters actually existed. It is as if the Creationists have won without a struggle. The concept of religion, as reflected in the fiction of mythology, no longer fits the paradigm. Reality is electronic, and paper is fiction. Bells, bells, bells, bells, bells, bells, bells! At least as I get shelved with dusty books, I will be in a familiar environment with gods, monsters, and dinosaurs. This is the world I was born into and which will not long survive the passing of my generation.

4 thoughts on “The Bells

  1. Dr. Jim

    It’s not quite that bad up here at the U. of Lethbridge, but I recognize a lot of what you are suffering through.
    One trick that works for me is to give a number of short writing assignments, usually on a textbook chapter or a simple academic article. 300 words usually does the trick and are fairly quick to grade. I ban the use of direct quotations. I also give the students a sample assignment (on a different topic, but from the same article, if possible) with everything ruthlessly well documented.
    Right on the course outline or assignment instruction sheet I tell them that serious errors in English or documentation, or misrepresenting the article’s meaning will result in a failing grade. I then carry through with the threat with ruthless abandon for student’s feelings.

    After they stew in their failure for a few days, I offer to let them rewrite the assignment in proper English and properly documented. A number will come through. Tell them the next assignment will be judged equally sharply.

    I find that by the time these folks write a longer paper at the end of term there are very few systematic errors in documentation and the quality of English is much better too. It is hard, but I get a lot of students saying “thanks” afterward. Many do appreciate it, especially if you give them the sample assignment and agree to look over drafts and things. Few students even know what is expected in writing. Many have never really had to meet high standards, and some are even surprised when they find they CAN meet them (and when they finally start getting good grades for good work, it is very satisfying for me, too!).

    There is a lot of marking, but if the assignments are based on the weeks reading (and due ahead of the actual discussions in class) you know that most of the students have read, struggled, and understood, the readings.

    Like

  2. Hi Steve. I know what chaff is. I didn’t know footnotes were dead. Must be something in the water because I just wrote a similar blog for tomorrow’s post. Strange to think my kids will never know a world without a computer. Thank you for your post. All the best.

    Like

  3. Henk van der Gaast

    Hmm.. so there are other people in my cave.

    Its almost a challenge to get “down and dirty” with all the misinformation on the net.

    I suppose if you really look back on things, we weren’t any better when we started.

    Like

  4. Jonathan

    I’m sorry. What do we do instead of footnoting now?
    Make stuff up and hope it sounds credible? Gleefully refuse to acknowledge anyone else’s work?
    On second thought, maybe I don’t want to know.

    Like

Leave a reply to Henk van der Gaast Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.