The Mist in the Pulpit

With the teaching schedule I have, vacations are not viable. One semester blends into another like some demonic tapestry with blurred edges between the somewhat discrete components. Breaks just aren’t part of the picture. While my family is on a well-deserved vacation, I’ve been home doing class prep and lecturing. On those nights when I have no classes, I sometimes watch a movie to hear the sound of human voices. This week one of my picks was The Mist.

My fascination with horror films stretches back to my college days, concurrent with my first degree in religious studies. Never a slasher fan, I’ve preferred the more thoughtful movie that has a (hopefully) profound message. I’d never read Stephen King’s novella on which this movie was based, so I didn’t know what to expect. All I knew was “there’s something in the mist.” The build-up was great until the creatures were shown – after that it became a standard monster flick. A human menace arises in the form of Mrs. Carmody, a religious zealot who is convinced the mist is the apocalypse. As the survivors try to form some plan of action, Carmody’s preaching becomes more and more strident and self-convinced as the “wicked” die and the “righteous” are spared. Not having read the book, I’m not sure if her over-the-top rhetoric originated with King or with Frank Darabont, the screenwriter/director.

I have often posted on the relationship of monsters and religion, but The Mist is almost too easy to cite. Perhaps released too late to make it into Douglas Cowan’s Sacred Terror, the connection between religion and fear is patent and bald. Mrs. Carmody’s religion, apart from being very generally Christian, is hard to identify. She insists on human sacrifice while constantly referencing the Bible. Although there are examples of human sacrifice in the Bible, that particular cultic activity is never advocated for monster invasions or the apocalypse. Carmody is a parody of religious over-reaction to the unfamiliar and dangerous. In her insistence that others take her point of view, the caricatured Carmody becomes a danger that threatens the community. It is left indeterminate whether her followers survive or not.

The religious agitator is a trite and tired character, but one that has instant recognition value. In The Mist, however, I came for the mystery and stayed for the monsters. Mrs. Carmody could have said much more by saying much less.

8 thoughts on “The Mist in the Pulpit

  1. Henk van der Gaast

    You never mention Clive Barker! I realise that most of his movie productions are feeble but his books are astounding.

    You have canvassed the wicker man movie, try Clive’s “imajica”. All the things that you appear to like are there.

    That Bart Starr evil that lurks in the back ground of most of King’s books appears as a shiney beautiful but horrendous evil in Clives.

    I don’t read horror like King as Horror, nor do I read Clive as horror. Its the most beautiful consistent SF/Fantasy there is.

    Having said that, I have never read a horror book, just a great fantasy book and every horror film i have ever seen is a great fantasy film or a failure.

    Its all in the mythology the author gives you. As you know, I aint too good at the mythology, but I’m damned (sic) well like it!

    Like

    • Steve Wiggins

      Thanks for the tips, Henk! I’ve only ever seen Clive Barker movies, never read the books. I’ll take a peek one of these days when I get the chance.

      Like

      • Andrew Vogel

        Well if you ever come to any conclusions let me know. I saw this movie in the theater and I feel like the ending is significant – I just don’t know how still.

        Like

  2. Jonathan

    The key point in so many of these types of movie is that the survivors of the menace are often more of a threat than the original menace. Witness any good zombie movie, particularly.

    Personally, I thought the Carmody characteeization was a bit ham-fisted and amateurish, but I understood the role that she was meant to take.

    The beauty of these plots is that they’re not man vs nature/monster. They’re really man vs man.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.