10 Questions

This week’s Time magazine’s 10 Questions feature is directed to Stephen Hawking. Predictably, the first one concerns God. “If God doesn’t exist, why did the concept of his existence become almost universal?” a reader asks. I was less concerned with the answer than with the implications of the question itself. The very question represents a paradigm shift. Time was, such questions were directed to local clergy. The minister had the answers. To be sure, many millions, if not billions, of people regularly rely on their clergy for divine guidance. I used to teach clergy, so I am wary. Today, however, we need to know if all the answers fit. To find out if God exists, ask a scientist.

Theologians have earned their reputation as inscrutable doyens of the unspeakable. I have been involved in higher education in the field of religion for nearly twenty years and when I read theologians I am left scratching my head and asking “what?” Erudite to the point of being obtuse, the issues and methods of theologians address the unknowable. Much of it is idle speculation. The specialists, however, must earn their keep. Deans are impressed by what they can’t understand. God himself, I’m sure, wonders what some of it means. Is it any wonder that the average citizen would rather ask Dr. Hawking than ask some obscure theologian?

Religion and science are bound to bump at the borders like the parallel universes of string theory. Both are concerned with explaining things. Science has a proven track record of presenting verifiable results while theology has produced a poke full of intangibles. I am the first to admit to being a working-class Joe who has no special knowledge. What I’ve learned has come from the many classes I’ve endured and the books I’ve read. As far as I can tell, none of it comes directly from God. In my mind’s eye I reverse the situation. I see a popular theologian, take your pick (I have trouble conjuring the moniker of a household-name theologian), being featured in 10 Questions and the first query being, “What is M-Theory?” I can imagine the convoluted answer.

4 thoughts on “10 Questions

  1. It was one of my law professor’s (Vine DeLoria) contention that man creates God in his own image. The more I see of religions and how they are exploited for man’s ends the more I am sure he is right. Though I do believe there is still something bigger than we are. We’re just too small to define it, whether scientist or theologian.

    Like

  2. I wonder if one of the issues is that scientists tend to be aware that they are working within a limited axiomatic system and therefore may be less in danger of reifying their results. I sometimes get the impression that theologians believe that the terms of their arguments are identical with the things they signify.

    Like

  3. Ian

    What a great observation. Scientists’ authority is very interesting isn’t it. The flip side is played out in anti-vaccination and anti-global warming.

    Theologians: inscrutable doyens of the unspeakable.

    Needs to go on a poster.

    Like

Leave a reply to Piper Bayard Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.