Trite Lite

Fresh out of that improbable world called Nashotah House, I was introduced to a jarring concept while in Oshkosh: a Hasidic rapper called Matisyahu. The strange image brewed in my head did not match the reality of this persona, but the very concept of a religious conservative engaging in protest music just didn’t seem to fit. I make no claims to musical expertise, but I did grow up in the 60’s and 70’s, and I know authentic protest when I hear it. Rap began as a countercultural rebellion, and I knew age had its gray fingers wrapped around me when a friend in grad school claimed that rap was “the end of civilization as we know it.” Civilization didn’t end, it simply evolved.

Rap started to become mainstream, as happens to all radical movements when they become “cool” and the aging performers join their aged fans. Then along comes Hi-Caliber, the pathetic Republican attempt to appeal to the hip, the young, the impressionable. The Tea Party rapper (Zac the Rapper?) inveighs his tired message that progress is bad, privileging the wealthy is good, for the Bible tells me so. And the public sips it in. As a person who can’t help but overthink things, it alarms me how trite answers are easily accepted by so many people. If a person stops to think about the implications of issues, the simple solutions proffered by Tea Partiers simply don’t solve anything, no matter how many rappers, twitterers, or ravers they get on their side. Rather than exercise mental rigor, most voters see the shiny glitz and pull the voting booth curtain. Perhaps my friend was right after all.

I have to face the fact that I’m aging into a guy who casts a nostalgic, longing glance back to the sixties of my youth with a sentimental eye. The cardboard-cutout world of the 1950s seems that it was insubstantial, staged even, compared to the psychedelic colors I first saw through childhood’s wondering gaze. I heard protesters on the radio and saw them on television while being raised in a conservative environment. And even though I never personally rebelled, being the Bible-reading type, I secretly admired those who had the courage to challenge the social evils of the day and damn the consequences. Now I switch on the radio and hear conservative fat-cats clipping out pithy rhymes upholding the man. Where is the authenticity? It all makes me want to turn on, tune in, and drop out.

Authentic Republican wrapper

4 thoughts on “Trite Lite

  1. I want to as well. I’ve been feeling tension for some time, but maybe about 3-4 years ago now (watching immigration debate on CNN on a break) I realized that the political culture has become completely unrecognizable to me – and I’m sure (having been through a row of “Don’t tread on me” flags in the usually-benign Iowa countryside) that the whole world is different and hostile. I would really like to be a part of some counter-culture, though perhaps academe by itself is that counter-culture.

    My advisor’s cousin is a hard-rock Hasidic rabbi – which makes a startling contrast (geeky, socially awkward Sanskritist vs. a guy with sidelocks who puts Hendrix to shame).


    • Steve Wiggins

      Hi Wulfila,

      Yes, this is discouraging. Long ago I accepted that there is no such thing as utopia, but I had hoped America might struggle itself up to a neutralopia or something better than what is going on all around us. Which would be better: Rollerball or Soylent Green?


  2. Henk van der Gaast

    Jonathan E! Jonathan E! Jonathan E!

    oops, I’ve outed myself again…

    Science fiction is a great way of positing about utopias. You dont jave to get a lot of justification out of the way, just fill the spaces with (hopefully great) plot line.

    I cant actually work out what your tea party protesters want. Every slogan seems to contradict a slogan by another tea party adherent. As usual, the main thrust has been buried from the scrutiny of others bandying their agendas in the framework of a movement.

    If the tea party is about economic reform (as it appears) its simplistic and is fair. Everyone gets to keep that basket case called the health system. Hardly an issue of fairness in my book.

    As I said in the next post (I am psychic) everyone has their 15 minutes of glory. Sadly the Teaparty is doing it collectively.


    • Steve Wiggins

      The sad part, Henk, is that people in the States are easily taken in by such showboating. Otherwise it is hard to comprehend the Reagans, Schwartzeneggers, and Venturas that haunt our political landscape.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.