Material to Ponder

EndOfMaterialismFrom my youngest days I remember wanting to be a scientist. This desire was tempered with a real fear of Hell and wish to please. In my career, it seems, the latter won out. Well, mostly. I never planned on being an editor, but it was clear that I missed the hard-core science courses and would always lack scientific credibility. You see, I believed what scientists said, and that included science teachers in high school. To this day I still believe in the back of my mind that you can’t really see atoms with a microscope. One of my teachers had said it was impossible, and although electron microscopes were still a long way off, it was clear that atoms were just too small. The force of materialism first hit me in ninth grade physics. If what I was hearing was true, then if you had enough information, you could figure out the whole universe. But what of Hell?

I read Charles T. Tart’s The End of Materialism because of my need for reassurance. Materialism leaves me cold. To find a scientist who feels the same way is a bonus. Not all authorities agree that we’re just excited atoms that can be seen. Tart is willing to consider the spiritual as part of what the evidence reveals. He explores it in the context of psi rather than in the doomed attempt to test religions empirically, but he does make a case for more to this universe than Horatio’s philosophy ever dared dream. And some of that more is decidedly not physical. It’s what we know from our experience of the world. We don’t only reason, we also feel. I have to wonder if reason is really the friend of materialism after all.

You can’t walk across Manhattan without seeing an ambulance most days. Often they’re called out to collect some unfortunate homeless person who collapses from our collective neglect. If we are only matter, then why do we bother to assist those in distress? It’s just a little electricity and some chemicals in a biological organ, right? Consciousness is only an illusion, after all. Unless, of course, the person suffering is a prominent scientist. Then we should all make way for the ambulance lest we lose an asset of great value. Materialism is insidious in its take-no-captives mentality. Feel what you will, there’s nothing more to life than physical stuff. You can make a good living believing that. Why is it that I’m suddenly thinking of Hell again?

2 thoughts on “Material to Ponder

  1. Dan

    That’s too cynical a view of materialism. Our mind may be reducible to physio-chemical brain states, but the higher level emergent property (conciousness) can be given value by those that share in that property. Indeed, if materialism is true, values and morals are a matter of human consensus (see J.L. Mackie’s Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong). I value sentient beings because I am a sentient being and I can feel empathy for like-minded creatures. Even differently conscious beings can be given value, though also differently from that of fellow Homo sapiens.

    As a monist, I reject beliefs in disembodied minds and the afterlife. The mind is bound to physical matter (i.e. gray matter). Damage the brain and the mind is affected. No dualist philosophy can sufficiently explain the mind’s dependence on the brain.

    And as for Charles Tart, I have read about him being a parapsychologist. I don’t have much sympathy for parapsychology. It is a field with no success, no evidence, no meat. William James may impress us with his Will to Believe, but I am more partial to Bertrand Russell’s Logical Empiricism.


    • Thanks, Dan.

      Consciousness is the elephant in the gray matter room, I believe. If it is emergent, then it sure feels real!

      Tart is a parapsychologist. There is, however, considerable evidence that parapsychological phenomena do occur, under laboratory conditions. Tart (and others willing to read the reports) discusses this at length.

      But then, these are just the musings of excited atoms early in the morning. I wouldn’t take it too seriously.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.