The question’s not as simple as whether chocolate and peanut butter go together. What is it with horror and the Bible? A number of us have explored that question in book form, but probably the most prolific is Brandon R. Grafius. His Scared by the Bible is a mapping through terrain that will feel foreign to some: if you live for the beach in summer, why would you fly to Antarctica to visit the South Pole instead? Part of the reason is clearly that the Bible isn’t the rainbow-and-unicorn book that it’s often made out to be. Some parts—not a few—are pretty scary. That’s Grafius’ entry point into how horror and the Bible are surprisingly compatible. Interestingly, we had similar starts down this path. A Bible given to us by a grandmother when we were a child, and the determination to read it. My world was a bit more hellfire and brimstone than Grafius’ but we’ve ended up near the same place.
Often I thought, as I was reading it, “Are people going to get both these references?” (i.e., both the biblical story and the horror movie being cited). After all, many Christian denominations still teach that horror is not helpful at best, and satanic at worst. I just wonder how many of us there are who never found watching horror a spiritual problem. I grew up thinking about death a lot. Part of this was because Evangelical children’s literature raised the question of where would you spend eternity if you died today. Seriously, some of the stories I read, along with Dick and Jane, still scare me today. Religion often uses fear for its own purposes. So does the Bible. Grafius comes down to this at the end, asking if it’s intentional on the Bible’s part.
It seems to me that this is an important question to explore. Religion has been weaponized through fear since at least the Reagan years. More recently it has been aimed specifically at us “evil” liberals and our “culture of death” even as conservatives rain bombs on Iran. We desperately need to understand religion’s now very intentional use of fear to retain power. People are afraid. They have reason to be. Generally it’s not the emotional issues politicians hand-pick to garner votes. Yes, the Bible is a source of fear. Horror films are often also a source of scary thoughts. They do have a lot in common. We just need someone to come along with an open jar of peanut butter to run into someone eating a chocolate bar.
