Stormy Weather

The privileging of one literature over others is problematic. Of course, the entire industry of biblical studies is built around such preferential treatment. And so is a large share of Christianity. I’ve just finished reading William H. Jennings’ Storms over Genesis: Biblical Battleground in America’s Wars of Religion. For someone who has taught Genesis before there wasn’t too much new material in here, but it strikes me as a very good primer for those who wonder about why the issues of gender inequality, global warming, and evolution remain firmly entrenched in evangelical minds, and therefore, our society. Just the first three chapters of Genesis, as Jennings points out, have led to the much of the irrational, at times inane, arguments that just won’t go away. Tea Party kinds of issues.

At the base of it all is the concept that Genesis somehow represents the way the world is supposed to be (rather than the way it actually is). As if seconding my choice of bus reading, The Economist recently published an article on Glen Rose, Texas. I’ve known about Glen Rose since I was a child. There, in a bizarre twist on the Flintstones, locals claim human and dinosaur footprints intermingle in a nearby creek bed. As the article points out, some locals see this as evidence of young earth creationism—seems Fred and Wilma missed the ark along with Dino. For decades paleontologists have tried to explain that the “human” tracks are actually dinosaur tracks as well. Given their size and stride, if they were human Adam must’ve been a giant. Despite the science, the myth persists. Even the article in The Economist doesn’t give the scientific answer.

It would be difficult to find a book more influential than Genesis. It would also be difficult to find one that is less scientific. Anyone who has studied ancient societies knows that they delighted in telling outlandish stories to explain the origin of the world. After all, there were no eyewitnesses. No channel 11 helicopters hovering overhead to bring you the story live. It all comes from mistaking a good story for a good book. In an era when evidence of evolution literally abounds, we still have nearly half the population of this technological nation trying to make room for the Valley of the Gwangi. Jennings may not hold the answers to all the problems Genesis raises, but if people would read Storms over Genesis, we might be able to afford a little more energy to solving global warming rather than running from dinosaurs in Texas.

3 thoughts on “Stormy Weather

  1. Gender inequality? That’s not how it’s been taught to me. Being created first does not make men better. Being made out of dust rather than a rib isn’t a sign of dominance. The church does reinforce gender roles, but the roles were not taught to me in a way that made me feel inferior to anyone.

    If anything, the roles gave me a foundation to build on. They weren’t a cage I was locked into, Since I never had children with my husband from another culture, I had to figure some of it out for myself, anyway.

    The one thing that was pounded into me for as long as I can remember is that God looks at us all the same. He doesn’t look at me and see a white evangelical woman. He looks at me and sees Jane, who is just as valuable as anyone else in the world – and He expects me to look at everyone else the same way.

    Are there sects and religious traditions that enforce male dominance. I’ll give you that, but to put forth the myth that evangelicals promote gender inequality just doesn’t add up with my experience or what I see happening in the church today. It’s great political rhetoric, but it’s getting pretty stale.

    Like

    • Steve Wiggins

      Thanks, Jane. My experience being raised evangelical suggests just the opposite. Many evangelicals, beginning with Paul, continuing through Tertullian and Augustine and right up to Jerry Falwell disagree with your reasonable assessment. The Roman Catholic Church agrees with them as a matter of principle. There are enlightened evangelicals, just not enough of them.

      Like

  2. Paul’s not so bad if you put him into his cultural context – same with some of the others. They were down-right women’s libbers given their day. LOVE your wife? That was revolutionary! Jerry Falwell seems like a carnival character to me, but I do like Rick Santorum (who I know makes you crazy). I’ll admit my evangelical roots keep me on the fence when it comes to evolution and global warming. I’m one of those people who can hold knowledge in one hand while holding faith in the other and not feel like they need to be resolved immediately.

    I confess that when someone says evangelical, I immediately think Protestant, not Roman Catholic. I definitely consider the Pope’s church gender-challenged, along with several other problems. So see, we agree once again.

    I’m sorry you were brought up in an atmosphere that was so difficult, but in spite of the nut jobs out there, not all evangelicals are repressive, uneducated Neanderthals. When I was younger an earnest group of believers virtually held me prisoner at a prayer meeting, demanding that I be filled with the spirit and speak in tongues. It was a horrible, frightening experience, but I realized, even then, I was dealing with some weird fringers and you can find loonies in any group.

    The historical church, taken as a whole, has plenty of baggage, that’s for sure, but there’s a lot of enlightened evangelicals, like me, around – or I’d change teams. I commented on your post because it seems to me that the more politically correct we become as a nation, the more acceptable it is to marginalize traditional religious groups. There’s a lot wrong with the world today, but nice people who are doing everything they can to build bridges into the community around them and help whoever is in need shouldn’t be so scary – and if they happen to embrace religious traditions that don’t measure up to the latest report in Scientific American, that doesn’t mean they hate women, love polluting rivers and haven’t read Darwin. (And I’m smiling as I write this, not grinding my ax.)

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.